The Pittsburgh Tribune-Review carried a story by Craig Smith on May 4th concerning the firing of a Roman Catholic parish’s youth music director. The youth music director was fired by the “pastor” of the Roman Catholic Church in Sewickley, PA. The pastor is being backed up by the Pittsburgh Diocese of course.
The youth music director, Mary Lynn Pleczkowski, is the wife of a PNCC priest who serves with the United States Air Force. He was recently stationed in Afghanistan.
Mrs. Pleczkowski had worked for the R.C. parish for fifteen (15) years. Many in the parish were saddened by her sudden firing.
The Roman Catholic Church is using a little known provision in its ‘laws’ called the ‘Cardinal’s clause’ as the reason for the firing.
Mrs. Pleczkowski is now without work. I imagine that that’s quite a burden, you know with two children and with your husband away serving his country – most recently in harms way.
Now, the stated reason for using the ‘Cardinal’s clause’ is because the R.C. Church does not recognize Father and Mrs. Pleczkowski’s marriage. Father Pleczkowski was a R.C. priest who left the R.C. Church to get married. He subsequently joined and was accepted by the PNCC as a priest in good standing.
The R.C. Church has a double standard concerning PNCC clergy. They recognize our orders and other sacraments (the Tribune Review story states they do not which is in error), but refuse to recognize PNCC clergy in good standing who used to be R.C. priests.
This double standard opens up all sorts of problems and personally I think it is motivated more by “hurt feelings” than by good theology.
Imagine this. A R.C. parishioner finds him/herself in urgent need of the sacraments. They avail themselves of the sacraments from a PNCC priest. Should they have checked the ‘do not call’ list before doing so?
Many people who read this blog would understand the differences between sacraments being valid and licit (from an R.C. perspective). But what about that poor parishioner who hears half truths from certain R.C. pastors who carry an animus toward the PNCC? These pastors aren’t even familiar with the information printed in the back of the missalette they use.
Speaking of animus:
The October 2005 United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) and PNCC joint press release on the R.C. – PNCC dialog had this little tidbit in it:
Sacramental sharing between PNCC military chaplains and Roman Catholic military personnel was also discussed.
Actually that statement has been in a few of the releases. Hmmm, I wonder if someone got upset because Father Pleczkowski gave communion to an R.C. soldier (which is perfectly allowable)?
Here’s a few excerpts from the Pittsburgh piece: ‘Cardinal’s clause’ used in church firing
The use of a little known Catholic statute to fire a music leader at a Sewickley church has outraged some parishioners and divided a congregation that has been through controversy before.
The Rev. Ed Wichman removed Mary Lynn Pleczkowski from her paid position as associate music director at St. James Church because she’s married to a priest affiliated with a church the Vatican does not recognize.
Wichman invoked the “cardinal’s clause,” which, in part, prohibits people whose marriages are not recognized by the church from holding church positions. Pleczkowski married her husband, Robert, in a Methodist church about 20 years ago. He now is a priest in the Polish National Catholic Church.
The marriage didn’t show up on the radar screen until Wichman was assigned to the parish, Pittsburgh Catholic Diocese spokesman the Rev. Ron Lengwin said. Wichman attended Mt. St. Mary’s Seminary in Emmitsburg, Md. with Pleczkowski’s husband roughly two decades ago.
St. James announced Sunday that Pleczkowski was “moving on” from her post.
Pleczkowski did not return numerous calls. Wichman referred calls to Lengwin.
Pleczkowski had worked as associate music director at St. James for about 15 years.
Her dismissal stunned the youth choir Pleczkowski oversaw and hurt her family, said friends and relatives.
“She got kids involved in the choir, and that sparked them to be more involved in the parish,” said St. James parishioner Anna Villella, of Sewickley. “I understand there are rules and regulations but … this is tremendously difficult on the children.”
“Everyone is devastated. She is like a second mom,” said Lacey Gerle, 18, of Sewickley, who has been in the choir at St. James since the sixth grade.
…
A person who posted a comment at Kelly B’s Blog on Your Sewickley may have had a similar clue about revenge.
For info about St. James Parish (they have four websites):
St. James’ Diocesan website
St. James’ own website (Mrs. Pleczkowski is still listed under the Parish Directory, Music Ministry)
St. James’ music ministry website (Mrs. Pleczkowski is prominently listed)
St. James School
From their April 16, 2006 bulletin (note PDF format):
SHORT SERMON
We were called to be witnesses –
not lawyers and judges.
The URI for the bulletin is in part “/bull/20060416”. Yep.
Check out the “Marriage Moments” articles from the bulletins. Ooops, not you Mrs. Pleczkowski.
[dels]blogs4god/polity[/dels]