Top twenty theological influences
Ben Meyers of Faith and Theology presents a list of his top twenty theological influences prompted by Aaron Ghiloni’s post on the same issue.
Mr. Meyers states:
Aaron is absolutely right —“ our theology may be influenced by books, but the deepest theological influences are almost always non-literary. These are the things that really construct us and constitute us as persons —“ only subsequently do we also make a few minor alterations through the influence of books.
So I’ve decided to join in with my list of —top 20+1 theological influences,— not in rank order.
- The Holy Eucharist – most particularly in the reception of the Eucharist, but also in the adoration and contemplation of the Eucharist.
- St. Casimir’s R.C. Church —“ God glorified. Thundering homilies in the days of the Tridentine Rite Holy Mass (up through 1974 believe it or not). Solemn liturgies, deep devotion, beautiful vestments, art, light and architecture. The church is modeled on the Hagia Sophia and is a magnificent example of Byzantine architecture. Everything in the church pulls you up to God.
- St. Anthony —“ a special patron to whom my mother was deeply devoted. As a child, St. Anthony held the baby Jesus and found lost stuff. As an adult —“ getting to know him better, I understood that effective preaching is a grace and motivator to conversion.
- Traditions around the holidays —“ the Polish traditions that brought family together and which were always centered on the faith. Not tradition for the sake of tradition, but tradition for the sake of learning about, glorifying, and praising God.
- Polish hymns —“ as a young person I didn’t understand a word, but my mom told me what they meant. They moved me to great heights and to tears, just by the music and the interpretation of the singers.
- Gorzkie Żale devotions (Bitter Lamentations) —“ the sorrows of Christ’s passion and death sung and prayed —“ all from the perspective of the Blessed Virgin. I could feel her pain and it still moves me to tears.
- Adoration of the Holy Cross on Good Friday —“ kissing the five wounds —“ loving Jesus.
- Sister Agnese —“ my aunt and a Felician sister. Total dedication to God and to her work. The joy of a community of faith.
- Illness —“ being a diabetic and knowing first hand the difficulties of illness. Understanding that there is a place of joy with no more suffering or sickness.
- Adoption —“ being adopted into my family and several others. Love by choice as a reflection of God choosing us.
- Travel —“ never without church, never without family —“ and being thankful for the opportunity. The vastness of God’s world and our human connection by His design.
- My father’s death (I was 4 years old) —“ understanding the value of saying you are sorry and seeking reconciliation. He disciplined me the night before he died —“ I never told him I was sorry.
- The PNCC —“ and a richness of theology. The Word as sacrament, regeneration and a choice for Christ.
- Negative R.C. experiences —“ triumphalism, absolutism, minimalism, legalism, church closings, abuse (a couple tried with me), extravagance, and others. Yes, I know —“ not the Church, but the sins of weak men, yet we are obliged, as partners with Christ, to cooperate in how we define ourselves.
- Doing the things I said I would never do —“ God’s ways are not our ways, and we are not in charge.
- Children —“ you can intellectualize why you can’t, shouldn’t, or mustn’t but none of it makes sense in light of the reality. The best experience is seeing your children grow in the womb, followed by the experience of their birth. This was also brought home to me in a meeting where a woman with very strong ‘convictions’ about over population, not bringing children into the world, etc. —“ a 1960’s type protester —“ lamented of her loss.
- A Full Gospel Church elder —“ hearing him speak of the Spirit.
- Death —“ my mother was the youngest in her family (10 children) and my sister and I didn’t arrive until late in our parents’ 30’s. Most of my relatives were quite a bit older. My father died when I was four and so began a procession of death. Christ is our hope and our promise.
- My grandmother (Mary who we called Busha) who loved us so much. She and my aunt moved in with us after my dad died. She gardened (everything she touched grew), cooked, pickled, shoveled, swept, played with us kids, never spoke a word of English, and was the matriarch and center around which family gathered. She stood strong until a stroke at the age of 91. Every evening she would sit in the large chair in her room and pray the rosary or the chaplet of St. Terese allowing us to sit at her feet to watch, learn and understand.
- My grandfather (Louis) who loved us so much. We would walk —“ to get fried chicken or go to Golembiewski’s for toys. He would take us on the bus to the zoo or the museum. We would fall asleep on his side on car rides to his house. He was a man of dignity, loyalty, honor, and great love.
- Growing up in a house full of women – understanding the difficulties they faced in healthcare, the job market, in dealing with men who thought that they had all the answers. A lesson in empathy at a minimum.
Great, moving list!
Hi, I beleive your aunt Sr. Mary Agnese may have been the principal of St. James school in Basking Ridge, NJ. If this is indeed your aunt please let me know how she is. I was one of her “First Born”. Sister Agnese’s name for the first class to graduate from St. James. Happy Easter. John Taylor
My list:
Anglican chant did for me what Polish hymns did for you.
The prose, cadence and orthodoxy in spite of its framers of the old Book of Common Prayer.
Like you a provincial (not a putdown) conservative parish that was a holdout against ‘the changes’ only mine was externally middle-of-the-road Anglican so like you I was formed by eastward celebrations.
Crypto-Anglo-Catholics who started to teach me Catholic doctrine and a few practices at that parish, especially the man who prepared me for confirmation.
The Eucharist.
The Mother of God.
A few positive modern RC experiences that complemented but couldn’t substitute for my early formation, especially a ‘Search’ retreat with teen-agers. The love and community there, even though temporary, was therapeutic and yes, told me something about God.
Positive conservative RC experiences that I sought out and found:
The 1940s-trained ethnic-Irish monsignor who gave me traditional moral theology, showing me how to examine my conscience and make a confession, very important indeed.
The Rosary.
Benediction which I liked better than the Novus Ordo Mass.
Some of the negative RC experiences you had: the liberal nonsense imported from Protestantism mixed with the ‘minimalism’ and contempt for high church Thomas Day describes perfectly. (Not formative but it happened: A priest tried and failed to seduce me too – to be fair so did an Anglican priest – but I understood the faith well enough to deal with it.)
The friend who introduced me as a teen-ager to Byzantine Christianity. He was the son of WWII-exile Ukrainian Catholics.
The old-fashioned Anglo-Catholic parish that was a refuge for me at an awful modern RC college.
My late Tridentine Anglo-Catholic rector, an older Englishman and former British naval officer who’d hold quiet days (Anglican for days of recollection) in which he’d say of the crucifix ‘God is dying to forgive you if only you’d let him’, who was understanding in the confessional and who offered novenas that ‘the scandal of the attempted ordination of women be removed from the Anglican Communion’.
Russian Orthodoxy.
My parish priest and father confessor of the past 13 years, formed by traditional RC and the best of East and West.
Encounters with online religion good and bad.
Of late discovering and praying the divine office.
S. Clement’s, Philadelphia: Paul, Larry, Treat (now an RC Cistercian monk) and others.
John,
Happy Easter!
I doubt that my aunt served in Basking Ridge, NJ. She did serve in a school in Buffalo for a short time, but her chief duty, and nearly lifelong service, was as the Porter for the Motherhouse at Villa Maria in Buffalo, NY. Basking Ridge is served by the Immaculate Conception of the B.V.M. Province out of Lodi, NJ.
Young Fogey,
I will save my happy Easter for next Sunday. Thank you for your reflection. Sometimes we think our walk into the faith is a very solitary one. I mentioned this at our clergy conference before the Holy Mass of Chrism last week. When you stand with brothers who have arrived in places near to where you arrived, and when you each reflect on what sustains you, you find much in common — perhaps a slice of the unity our Lord and Savior spoke about in St. John’s Gospel.